After 15 seasons in the National Football League, safety Rodney Harrison announced that his playing days were over and he’s about to begin a new career as an analyst for NBC’s “Football Night in America” broadcasts.
Almost immediately, several media members, including those with votes for the Hall of Fame, began beating the drum for his induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, with Harrison himself leading the way.
"Yes, I think I belong in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.” Harrison said during a post-retirement interview with Sirius radio interview with Peter King and Bob Papa. “I don't have the Pro Bowls, but that's not because I didn't put up the numbers. Blaine Bishop had 70 tackles and one interception one year and he went to the Pro Bowl instead of me. It's an all-star game based on popularity. I was never about self-promoting. I was unselfish. I would never trade in the Super Bowls for Pro Bowls, believe me.”
Nancy Gay of FanHouse, who is one of the 44-person board of selectors, writes tonight that "
Rodney Harrison Demands Your Respect".
Sure there is a shortage of safeties in the Hall of Fame, which figures to change as players like Harrison and John Lynch come up for consideration in the next five years, as well as further down the road when active safeties such as Ed Reed, Troy Polamalu and Brian Dawkins become eligible.
But before the Hall of Fame selection committee takes action on any of these candidates, though, it needs to give serious consideration to a safety from a generation before them:
Kenny Easley.
The argument against inducting Easley into the Hall of Fame is that his career was too short, therefore he lacks the longevity and statistics of a Hall of Fame player. Easley only played seven seasons (89 games) in the NFL, three of which were shortened, either by injury (1986) or work stoppages (1982, 1987).
Theoretically, a player with less than six full seasons worth of games shouldn’t have statistics that are comparable to a pair of 15-year safeties like Harrison and Lynch.
Yet somehow, he does.
TacklesTackles were not an official statistic until 2001. Even now, tackles are tracked and accredited differently from team-to-team, so there is no uniform way of knowing exactly how many tackles a player actually had.
Because they each played for 15 seasons, both Harrison and Lynch have well over 1,000 tackles. Based on their unofficial tackle numbers from www.pro-football-reference.com, Lynch averaged 4.7 tackles per game, while Harrison averaged 6.37. Tracking down Easley’s tackle stats was a bit more difficult, but according to the Seahawks’ 2008 media guide, Easley had 326 tackles over the 51 games he played in the 1981, 1982, 1983, and 1985 seasons, which equals out to a 6.39 tackles per game average.
Even if Easley had averaged just 3 tackles per game in the 38 other games he played between the ’84, ’86 and ’87 season, which surely would be a severely low estimate, he still would’ve averaged over 5 tackles per game over his 89-game career.
Quarterback SacksBy far, Harrison’s 30.5 quarterback sacks is the crown jewel of his HOF resume. He’s the all-time leader among defensive backs in this category, and is one of only five defensive backs with 18+ sacks in a career.
Though dwarfed in comparison to Harrison’s total, Lynch’s 13 career sacks is an impressive number of sacks for a safety.
Easley had 8 official quarterback sacks in his seven-year career. Of course, sacks weren’t an official statistic until 1982, his second season in the NFL, so it’s possible, if not highly probable, that Easley also would’ve posted 10+ quarterbacks sacks in his career if:
a.) Quarterback sacks been an official statistic his rookie season, and
b.) His career wasn’t shortened by two work stoppages.
InterceptionsThroughout his career, Lynch wasn’t a prolific interception guy, never having more than three in a single-season. In his career, he totaled 26 interceptions, none of which were returned for a touchdown.
Harrison complemented his 30.5 quarterback sacks with 34 interceptions, making him the only 30/30 player in NFL history. That's an impressive feat, and Harrison also had 361 return yards and a pair of touchdowns, so not only was he good at intercepting the ball, he could do some damage with it after the catch, as well.
Easley led the AFC in interceptions in 1984 (10) and during his 7-year career, had 32 picks and 538 return yards and 3 touchdowns. Easley had nearly as many interceptions as Harrison, nearly as many return yards as Harrison and Lynch
combined, and of the three, had more touchdowns.
Have I mentioned that he accomplished those feats in less than half as many games than either Harrison and Lynch played?
Awards and AccoladesHarrison mentioned in his interview that Pro Bowls are a popularity contest, and that he went to just two Pro Bowls during his entire 15-year career can be explained away by his not being liked by his peers, particularly those on the offensive side of the ball.
Fair enough, but what about the Pro Football Writers of American naming Harrison to just three first-team All-Pro squads? (Blaine Bishop was named to three first-team All-Pro teams, as well.)
Lynch was a fixture in Hawaii, earning nine trips to the Pro Bowl during his 15-year career. Like Harrison, Lynch was often left off All-Pro teams, earning first-team honors on two occasions.
And then there’s Kenny Easley, who in seven NFL seasons, was voted to 5 Pro Bowls and was first-team All-Pro three times. Additionally, he was the NFL’s Defensive Rookie of the Year in 1981, the NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 1984 (one of only four safeties to win this award), and the Hall of Fame selection committee named him to the NFL’s 1980s All-Decade Team.
Ultimately, despite posting similar, if not better statistics than Hall of Fame candidates like Harrison and Lynch, and earning more
individual honors in his career than either Harrison or Lynch earned, because he only played seven seasons, Easley will continue to receive little to no consideration for the Hall of Fame.
And that’s a shame, because Easley was a truly dominant player who's worthy of Hall of Fame recognition.